More than a dozen media organizations challenged the government’s ban on the use of drones by journalists Tuesday, saying the Federal Aviation Administration’s position violates First Amendment protections for news gathering.
The organizations include the Cox Media Group, Gannett, Gray Television, Hearst Corp., Sinclair Broadcast Group, Tribune Co., the Radio-Television Digital News Association, the Associated Press, Scripps Media, Advance Publications, The McClatchy Co., the National Press Photographers Association, The National Press Club, The New York Times Co., the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press and The Washington Post.
The organizations filed a brief with the National Transportation Safety Board in support of aerial photographer Raphael Pirker. Pirker was fined $10,000 by the FAA for flying a small drone near the University of Virginia to make a commercial video in October 2011. He appealed the fine to the safety board, which hears challenges to FAA decisions.
An administrative law judge ruled in March that the FAA can’t enforce its policy against all commercial use of drones when the agency hasn’t issued regulations for those uses. The FAA has appealed the judge’s decision to the full five-member safety board. Agency officials have said they hope to issue regulations for the use of small drones later this year.
The FAA won’t currently issue drone permits to news organizations. Officials have sent warning letters to journalists found to have used small unmanned aircraft – most of them no bigger than a backpack – to take photos and videos. The agency suggested to one Ohio newspaper that it refrain from publishing video of a burning building taken independently by a drone hobbyist, even though hobbyists, unlike journalists, are permitted to fly drones, according to the brief.